Battle to replace PGMBM in £36bn Mariana case heads to appeal

The Mariana client committee can appeal a ruling blocking its bid to replace PGMBM with rival firm Bailey Glasser International.

Published:
November 17, 2026 1:50 PM
Need to know

The High Court previously ruled that the committee lacked authority to replace PGMBM with Bailey Glasser International.

The appeal will be heard over two days, with no date fixed. The justices suggested early January as a possibility.

The client committee in the £36 billion Mariana dam litigation has today won permission to appeal a High Court ruling that prevented it from replacing PGMBM with rival law firm Bailey Glasser International (BGI).

Lord Justice Fraser and Lord Justice Meade granted permission at a hearing at the Royal Courts of Justice on Tuesday in PGMBM Law Ltd v Marcelo Batista Santana Krenak and others.

The hearing saw Sa’ad Hossain KC, representing the committee, face Alan Maclean KC for PGMBM, formerly known as Pogust Goodhead, again, following their clash in the High Court last month.

On that occasion, Mr Justice Waksman had ruled that the committee lacked authority to terminate the firm’s retainer on behalf of more than 400,000 claimants or appoint BGI in its place. He also refused permission to appeal, prompting the committee to apply directly to the Court of Appeal.

The appeal will be heard over two days on a date yet to be fixed, although the justices suggested early January as a possibility.

Bringing the whole deck of cards down

The dispute centres on whether the committee’s powers to manage the litigation extend to changing lawyers collectively on the claimants’ behalf. Maclean, representing PGMBM, argued that those powers did not give the committee the right to “bring the whole deck of cards down” by terminating the firm’s retainer.

Advertisement

The committee voted in August to remove PGMBM, formerly known as Pogust Goodhead, after raising concerns about the firm and its litigation funder, Gramercy on settlement strategy. It sought to appoint BGI to take over the claims arising from Brazil’s 2015 Mariana dam disaster.

PGMBM argued that the committee could not terminate agreements made with individual clients. It also warned that termination without cause could expose claimants to approximately £2 billion in legal costs, equivalent to around £5,000 per claimant.

Waksman accepted the firm’s interpretation of the agreements, finding that the committee’s broad management powers did not authorise it to dismiss the solicitors on everyone’s behalf.

Today’s decision allows the committee to challenge that ruling.

Following the appeal, a 22-week trial to determine the amount of compensation payable in the Mariana litigation is due to begin in April 2027.

Responding to the court's decision, PGMBM issued a statement in which it said that permission to appeal was a procedural step and that the High Court ruling remained in place. The firm said it would defend the judgment and that its "focus is on moving the case forward in preparation for the April 2027 quantum trial".

Faranak Ghajavand, partner and head of commercial disputes at BGI, welcomed the decision, saying the appeal would allow the committee’s arguments about claimants’ ability to choose lawyers collectively to be fully heard.

Marcelo Krenak, chairman of the client committee, added: “The committee was created to be the collective voice of the victims of Mariana, and we will continue to defend their right to choose who represents them

This article has been updated to include responses to the ruling from PGMBM, BGI and client committee chairman Marcelo Krenak.

Advertisement
No items found.