Big Law’s billable hour faces a fresh challenge as Baker McKenzie changes course

As AI puts pressure on hourly billing, global chair Sunny Mann says that Baker McKenzie is shifting towards value-based fees.

Published:
November 16, 2026 8:15 AM
Need to know

Baker McKenzie is making value-based fees the default as AI speeds up legal work, while retaining hourly billing where appropriate.

Debate continues over whether AI will displace the billable hour or drive higher rates for senior advice.

Baker McKenzie is moving away from hourly billing as the default, with the firm urging its lawyers to use value-based pricing instead.

Global chair Sunny Mann told The Wall Street Journal that the shift is already underway, with clients charged for what is delivered rather than the time taken. Hourly billing remains an option where that approach isn’t possible, he told the paper.

“The hourly rate isn’t the right metric,” Mann said. “I think it’s a trend that you’ll see across the legal industry.”

The move addresses a growing challenge for law firms: as AI speeds up tasks such as due diligence and drafting and reviewing contracts, charging for time becomes harder to reconcile with the value of the advice provided.

Alternatives to hourly billing aren’t new. Firms already handle many matters on fixed fees but they are still often calculated using estimated hours. Value-based pricing puts the focus on the outcome of the work and what it is worth to the client.

Mann told the WSJ that clients have responded positively to discussions about the new model. He expects technology to shorten deal timetables, potentially increasing the volume of transactions that can be completed.

Finally, the death of the billable hour?

Bakers' move comes amid a change in mood music from many Big Law leaders.

Advertisement

Hilary Goodier, global chair of Ashurst Perkins Coie's NewLaw and consulting division, speaking at Harvey’s Sydney Forum in March, argued that AI is changing firms’ own financial incentives by undercutting the traditional leverage model, which relies on teams of junior lawyers billing substantial hours.

“The reason the billable hour is for the first time genuinely under real challenge is, suddenly, it’s in law firms’ best interest to think about a different and better way of doing this,” she said.

Former Allen & Overy senior partner Wim Dejonghe, co-founder of AI law firm Falcon, let actions speak louder than words, holding a mock funeral for the billable hour in a Belgian church to mark the startup firm's launch.

Kirkland & Ellis chair Jon Ballis has also signalled a growing role for value-based pricing. Speaking to the Financial Times in May about Kirkland’s planned $500 million investment in its own AI platform, he said the firm already used that approach on a number of matters.

“That trend will only continue and it will accelerate… and we’re going to lean into it,” he said.

Cooley CEO Rachel Proffitt sees an opportunity for firms to share more of their clients’ transaction risk, taking a similar approach to investment banks. Speaking on Semafor’s Compound Interest podcast, she suggested firms could share in the upside of successful deals while accepting that unsuccessful transactions might not pay for all the time spent.

Charles Russell Speechlys managing partner Simon Ridpath highlighted the internal incentives that may also need to change. “If you are incentivising your lawyers to operate on a time cost basis or by reference to a chargeable hour, does that drive efficiencies? You could argue quite the opposite,” he told Non-Billable.

Others expect a more gradual shift. Goodwin chair Anthony McCusker told Non-Billable that innovation would just reduce dependence on hourly billing, but added: “I don’t think it’s going to eliminate the billable hour.” Some clients still prefer a model they understand, he said.

Walker Morris managing partner Jeanette Burgess said her firm was preparing for more fixed fee work, while expecting hourly billing to remain valid for complex assignments and areas like face to face contract negotiations.

“As the pricing model evolves, I think it will all come down to value add. This will determine the price clients are prepared to pay. What is the value that the advice has added?” she said.

Or… the $100,000 billable hour?

Still, not everyone is convinced that the billable hour is totally dead.

Ironclad founder Jason Boehmig, who currently leads the legal vertical at OpenAI, offered a different take on X last week: “I think we will see the $100,000 billable hour before we see the end of the billable hour.”

Harvey’s head of product Ryan Samii joined the debate in support, arguing that a partner’s half hour, $1,500 strategy call can deliver far more value than hours of junior work, despite costing less.

Historically, that advice sat atop substantial associate fees. If AI absorbs the execution work, firms could charge much more for the partner’s time, Samii predicted.